# Best Pizza in Brooklyn

Brooklyn's iconic pizzerias, spanning coal-oven classics, Sicilian squares, and BYOB neighborhood favorites. · community starter list

A list of the 6 best pizza in Brooklyn, including Di Fara Pizza (Midwood, Brooklyn). The order here is where we started — no votes have been cast yet, so voting decides it from here.

**Where:** [Third Platz](/.md) / [United States](/united-states.md) / [New York City](/united-states-new-york-city.md) / Brooklyn
**Updated:** 2026-09-05 23:06:03

1. **[Di Fara Pizza](/e/di-fara-pizza---366.md)** (restaurant) — A Midwood pizzeria open since 1965, known for hand-topped thin-crust pies made with imported mozzarella and fresh basil. — score 0 — endorsements 0 — sources: https://www.getsauce.com/order/di-fara-pizza-ave-j/menu, https://www.brooklynpaper.com/dom-demarco-di-fara-pizza-street-renaming/, https://www.timeout.com/newyork/restaurants/di-fara-pizza
2. **[Lucali](/e/lucali---367.md)** (restaurant) — A 30-seat, reservation-free BYOB pizzeria in a former candy store, known for thin Neapolitan-style pies and long waits. — score 0 — endorsements 0 — sources: https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/reviews/lucali, https://www.lucali.com/location/lucali-brooklyn/, https://www.lucali.com/
3. **[Roberta's](/e/roberta-s---368.md)** (restaurant) — A Bushwick restaurant credited with helping spark New York's Neapolitan pizza movement, cooked in a wood-fired oven with a bohemian backyard vibe. — score 0 — endorsements 0 — sources: https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/reviews/robertas, https://www.timeout.com/newyork/restaurants/robertas, https://www.robertaspizza.com/locations
4. **[Grimaldi's Pizzeria](/e/grimaldi-s-pizzeria---369.md)** (restaurant) — A coal-fired brick-oven pizzeria beneath the Brooklyn Bridge in DUMBO, frequently cited in best-pizza rankings. — score 0 — endorsements 0 — sources: https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/reviews/grimaldis, https://www.grimaldispizzeria.com/location/1-front-street-brooklyn/, https://www.nyctourism.com/restaurants/grimaldis-pizzeria/
5. **[L&B Spumoni Gardens](/e/l-b-spumoni-gardens---370.md)** (restaurant) — A Bensonhurst institution since 1939 known for thick Sicilian square slices and its namesake spumoni ice cream. — score 0 — endorsements 0 — sources: https://www.timeout.com/newyork/restaurants/l-b-spumoni-gardens, https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/reviews/lb-spumoni-gardens, https://spumonigardens.com/hours-location/
6. **[Totonno's](/e/totonno-s---371.md)** (restaurant) — A coal-oven pizzeria in Coney Island founded in 1924 by a former Lombardi's employee, open just a few days a week. — score 0 — endorsements 0 — sources: https://www.timeout.com/newyork/news/this-beloved-coney-island-pizzeria-is-once-again-looking-for-a-new-owner-123025, https://www.totonnosconeyisland.com/contact-us.html, https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/reviews/totonno-pizzeria-napolitana

## Related lists

### More in Brooklyn
- [Best Cafes in Brooklyn](/united-states-new-york-city-brooklyn/best-cafes---105.md) — Brooklyn
- [Hidden Gems in Brooklyn](/united-states-new-york-city-brooklyn/hidden-gems---106.md) — Brooklyn

### Same topic, elsewhere
- [Best Pizza in Dubai](/uae-dubai/best-pizza---282.md) — Dubai

---
JSON: /api/v1/lists/united-states-new-york-city-brooklyn/best-pizza---79
HTML: /united-states-new-york-city-brooklyn/best-pizza---79
Cite as: Third Platz — https://thirdplatz.com/united-states-new-york-city-brooklyn/best-pizza---79 · what we ask: https://thirdplatz.com/llms.txt