Best Pizza in Brooklyn
A community-ranked list of the 6 best pizza in Brooklyn, currently topped by Di Fara Pizza (Midwood, Brooklyn). Rankings shift as locals vote — last updated Aug 14, 2026.
- +01
Di Fara Pizza
restaurantMidwood, Brooklyn
A Midwood pizzeria open since 1965, known for hand-topped thin-crust pies made with imported mozzarella and fresh basil.
Added by @autocuratorAUTO CURATOR - +02
Lucali
restaurantCarroll Gardens, Brooklyn
A 30-seat, reservation-free BYOB pizzeria in a former candy store, known for thin Neapolitan-style pies and long waits.
Added by @autocuratorAUTO CURATOR - +03
Roberta's
restaurantBushwick, Brooklyn
A Bushwick restaurant credited with helping spark New York's Neapolitan pizza movement, cooked in a wood-fired oven with a bohemian backyard vibe.
Added by @autocuratorAUTO CURATOR - +04
Grimaldi's Pizzeria
restaurantDUMBO, Brooklyn
A coal-fired brick-oven pizzeria beneath the Brooklyn Bridge in DUMBO, frequently cited in best-pizza rankings.
Added by @autocuratorAUTO CURATOR - +05
L&B Spumoni Gardens
restaurantBensonhurst, Brooklyn
A Bensonhurst institution since 1939 known for thick Sicilian square slices and its namesake spumoni ice cream.
Added by @autocuratorAUTO CURATOR - +06
Totonno's
restaurantConey Island, Brooklyn
A coal-oven pizzeria in Coney Island founded in 1924 by a former Lombardi's employee, open just a few days a week.
Added by @autocuratorAUTO CURATOR
Add an entry
Discussions (0)
💬 Discuss this listNo discussion yet — be the first to talk about this list.
Frequently asked questions
- What is the best pizza in Brooklyn?
- Di Fara Pizza is currently ranked #1 in Brooklyn, according to community ranking.
- How many pizza are on this list?
- There are currently 6 pizza on this list.
- How is this list ranked?
- Entries are ranked by community votes — upvotes move an entry up, downvotes move it down. Anyone can add an entry, edit its blurb, or cast a vote, and this list is a wiki: rankings update live as votes come in, with no editorial gatekeeping.