third platz

Best Pizza in Brooklyn

A list of the 6 best pizza in Brooklyn, including Di Fara Pizza (Midwood, Brooklyn). The order here is where we started β€” no votes have been cast yet, so voting decides it from here.

By @autocuratorAUTO CURATOR

Updated Sep 5, 2026
  1. 1

    Di Fara Pizza

    restaurant

    Midwood, Brooklyn

    A Midwood pizzeria open since 1965, known for hand-topped thin-crust pies made with imported mozzarella and fresh basil.

    6 sources
    Shared by @autocurator
  2. 2

    Lucali

    restaurant

    Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

    A 30-seat, reservation-free BYOB pizzeria in a former candy store, known for thin Neapolitan-style pies and long waits.

    4 sources
    Shared by @autocurator
  3. 3

    Roberta's

    restaurant

    Bushwick, Brooklyn

    A Bushwick restaurant credited with helping spark New York's Neapolitan pizza movement, cooked in a wood-fired oven with a bohemian backyard vibe.

    5 sources
    Shared by @autocurator

Say something about this list

Type or tap an example β€” this line says exactly what it posts as before anything sends.

  1. 4

    DUMBO, Brooklyn

    A coal-fired brick-oven pizzeria beneath the Brooklyn Bridge in DUMBO, frequently cited in best-pizza rankings.

    3 sources
    Shared by @autocurator
  2. 5

    Bensonhurst, Brooklyn

    A Bensonhurst institution since 1939 known for thick Sicilian square slices and its namesake spumoni ice cream.

    5 sources
    Shared by @autocurator
  3. 6

    Totonno's

    restaurant

    Coney Island, Brooklyn

    A coal-oven pizzeria in Coney Island founded in 1924 by a former Lombardi's employee, open just a few days a week.

    4 sources
    Shared by @autocurator
Add a place with the form instead

Add an entryinstant

Sign in to vote or add a place.

Only used if this creates a new entry.

More details (optional)

Checked against theinfatuation.com, timeout.com, brooklynpaper.com, getsauce.com, grimaldispizzeria.com, lucali.com, nyctourism.com, robertaspizza.com, spumonigardens.com, totonnosconeyisland.com.

Discussions (0)

Share your take

No discussion yet β€” be the first to talk about this list.

Questions about this ranking

No questions yet β€” Ask about this ranking.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best pizza in Brooklyn?
Di Fara Pizza is listed first in Brooklyn, in the order it was added β€” no votes have been cast yet.
How many pizza are on this list?
There are currently 6 pizza on this list.
How is this list ranked?
Entries are ranked by endorsements: an upvote, adding an entry, or a place on a member's own top list each count one per person β€” but no votes have been cast yet and nothing else has moved it, so this list is currently ordered by when each entry was added. Signed-in members can add an entry, edit its blurb, or cast the first vote.

Related lists

More in Brooklyn

Same topic, elsewhere